Views on improving the integrity of global capital markets
10 November 2011

Bringing Transparency to the Bond Market

Posted In: Market Structure, MiFID

Recently, the European Commission commenced its overhaul of securities markets regulation with the publication of the eagerly-awaited revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive, dubbed “MiFID 2”. Nearly a year in the making, the legislative package puts transparency at the forefront with ambitious proposals to shed light on trading in practically all financial instruments — from equities to bonds, derivatives, and even emissions trading allowances.

CFA Institute has contributed to the transparency debate with the publication of a recent report, An Examination of Transparency in European Bond Markets. The report, authored by Heidi Learner, CFA, examines the existing state of transparency in bond markets, drawing from the experiences of Italy and the United States — the two main markets that already require the publication of transaction details, such as price, time, and an indication of size, for certain fixed income securities. 

Market Structure
In evaluating the merits of greater transparency, the report compares the structure of the bond market to the equity market — the only asset class for which transparency requirements were applied under the original MiFID. Unlike equity markets, dealers play a significant role in bond markets, maintaining an inventory to trade bilaterally with customers before adjusting their exposures in the inter-dealer market. The sheer number of debt securities, the large sizes in which they trade, and, away from government bonds, the relative infrequency of transactions and low secondary market liquidity are all conducive to an over-the-counter (OTC) market structure. But as a consequence, investors must rely on indicative quotes provided by dealers, which can often be wide of the mark of executable prices.

Improving Information for Investors and Protecting Dealers
On the basis of the findings of its report, CFA Institute believes that careful implementation of post-trade transparency requirements in European bond markets can benefit investors by improving access to pricing information, reducing the information asymmetry between investors and dealers, and increasing competition in the provision of pricing quotes. More specifically, we make the following four recommendations:

  • Firstly, post-trade transparency requirements should be calibrated to take account of the size and liquidity of the issue. In other words, the information to be reported, and the timeliness with which that information is reported, should be a function of a bond’s liquidity characteristics. For example, it should be possible to delay the reporting of very large trades for an appropriate length of time to allow dealers to hedge their risks. Such calibration should address some fears that dealer positions would be needlessly exposed to the market from increased transparency.
  • Secondly, new transparency requirements should be implemented gradually to allow market participants time to adjust trading processes and systems, and to avoid the risk of a temporary liquidity shock.
  • Thirdly, authorities should develop standards over the content, format, and distribution of post-trade data. Investors need access to accurate and reliable information on bond transactions to facilitate the investment decision-making process. And consistent standards over trade reporting are necessary to facilitate the consolidation of post-trade data to provide investors with an aggregate view of bond market transactions.
  • Fourthly, with regards to pre-trade transparency, it seems that a uniform standard on the publication of quotes prior to trades being executed would be impractical at this stage. More generally, increased market acceptance of electronic trading platforms that continue to grow in Europe may lessen the immediate need for regulatory attention to this area.

The European Commission’s publication of MiFID 2 marks the beginning of the legislative process as the text moves on to the European Parliament and Council for negotiation. While many revisions will doubtless be made, one thing is certain: transparency will stay at the forefront of the agenda.

About the Author(s)
Rhodri Preece, CFA

Rhodri Preece, CFA, is Senior Head of Industry Research for CFA Institute. He is responsible for building and maintaining the global research function at CFA Institute, including leading the planning, coordination, and creation of research content across CFA Institute research platforms, which include the Future of Finance, the CFA Institute Research Foundation, the Financial Analysts Journal, and the Enterprising Investor blog. Preece formerly served as head of capital markets policy EMEA at CFA Institute, where he was responsible for leading capital markets policy activities in the Europe, Middle East, and Africa region. Preece is a former member (2014-2018) of the Group of Economic Advisers of the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) Committee on Economic and Markets Analysis. Prior to joining CFA Institute, Preece was a manager at PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP where he specialized in investment funds.

2 thoughts on “Bringing Transparency to the Bond Market”

  1. Donna says:

    Great piece, Mr Preece. I completely agree that that investors need access to accurate and reliable information on bond transactions to make fair and informed decisions. While searching, I came across, which offers investors real-time data and reporting info for asset-backed securities and derivatives. It seems like online platforms like this might be the next step in generating fair trade standards and a level playing field in the corporate bond market.

  2. Rhodri Preece, CFA says:

    Thanks Donna for your comment and for the link. Since our report was published we have been working with other investor groups to advance post-trade transparency standards. We remain engaged in the policy process on this in Europe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.